Banking Adjustments Before COVID-19

Early Signals: Banking Adjustments Before the COVID-19 Storm

Author Malcolm Henshaw
February 2020
14 min read

February 2020 marked a unique moment in the global banking sector. As the world watched the spread of a new virus in China, subtle signs began emerging within financial institutions that hinted at disruptions ahead.

Subtle

Changes in Lending Criteria

Cautious

Risk Management Approach

Digital

Acceleration in Banking

Even before the full impact of the COVID-19 pandemic was realized, banks started making adjustments to their lending practices as economic uncertainty grew. These early indicators, though modest at first, signaled a shift toward more cautious credit underwriting, increased scrutiny of risk, and enhanced preparation for potential volatility. As the situation unfolded, these early changes would prove pivotal in how the sector managed the coming crisis.

Observing a Shift in Lending Practices

Early Warning Signs

  • Subtle tightening of lending criteria

  • Refined underwriting standards

  • Increased emphasis on credit quality

Consumer Behavior

  • Consumer demand for loans remained strong

  • General optimism about personal finances

  • Limited awareness of pending economic disruption

In early 2020, reports indicated that banks had begun tightening their lending criteria ever so slightly. Financial institutions, though still active in their lending practices, refined their underwriting standards in anticipation of potential challenges in the near future. Economic forecasts were becoming more ambiguous, and banks, aware of the risks, started adjusting their strategies to protect themselves from potential future losses. While these shifts were still modest, they marked the beginning of a more cautious approach to lending in an increasingly uncertain environment.

Consumer demand for loans remained relatively strong during this time, but the mood among financial institutions was shifting. Lenders began placing more emphasis on credit quality, requiring stronger collateral, and considering the financial stability of borrowers more carefully. These small, early adjustments set the stage for deeper changes as the COVID-19 pandemic would soon shake the global economy and force banks to rethink their entire approach to lending.

Enhanced Risk Management Strategies

Risk Management Timeline

Q4 2019

Standard risk management practices with focus on traditional metrics

January 2020

First signs of more conservative risk models being implemented

February 2020

Increased emphasis on stress-testing borrower profiles against adverse scenarios

March 2020

Complete overhaul of risk management practices as pandemic impact becomes clear

Along with the subtle tightening of lending standards, many banks began reviewing and updating their risk management frameworks as concerns over economic stability increased. This proactive stance was designed to better prepare them for potential defaults and mitigate any potential disruptions that could arise from an increasingly volatile market. Financial institutions started incorporating more conservative risk models to assess borrowers, particularly focusing on stress-testing borrower profiles against a range of adverse economic scenarios.

This early precautionary action aimed to minimize exposure to risk by ensuring that even in uncertain times, lending portfolios would remain resilient. Stress tests became a vital tool in preparing for the unknowns ahead, enabling banks to make more informed decisions and adjust quickly if the economic landscape took a downturn. These adjustments in risk management were crucial in setting the foundation for more substantial changes that would follow, especially as the pandemic escalated in the months to come.

Consumer Lending Adjustments

Mortgage Applications

Moderate Decline

Early signs of caution but still relatively strong

Personal Loans

Modest Change

Slightly stricter approval criteria

Marginal Credit

Notable Decline

Increased scrutiny for borrowers with marginal credit profiles

The consumer lending space also saw early signals of adjustment, with banks beginning to moderate the approval volumes for personal loans and mortgages. While consumer demand for credit remained relatively strong at the time, especially for home mortgages and personal loans, lenders were growing more selective in approving applications. Particularly, borrowers with marginal credit histories faced more scrutiny during this period, as banks sought to protect themselves from potential defaults.

Despite these adjustments, consumer sentiment remained relatively positive in the early months of 2020. Many borrowers were still optimistic about the economy, and personal financial situations remained stable for the majority of the population. However, banks' cautious approach to lending was a clear indication that the banking sector was already preparing for the possibility of economic slowdowns. This early moderation in lending approvals was one of the first signs that banks were shifting toward more responsible credit practices, even in the face of initial optimism.

INDUSTRY INSIGHT
" The most forward-thinking financial institutions began adjusting their lending practices well before the full impact of COVID-19 was understood. These early preparations, though subtle at the time, positioned them for greater resilience through the crisis. "

- Financial Times Banking Report, March 2020

Commercial Credit and Business Loans

Sector-Specific Impact

↓ 15%

Tourism Lending

↓ 8%

Retail Sector

↓ 6%

Manufacturing

↑ 3%

Essential Services

In the commercial lending segment, a more significant shift began to take place. As economic indicators began to show mixed signals in early 2020, many banks started to adjust their risk appetites for business loans. Particularly, businesses in sectors that were vulnerable to global economic shifts—such as tourism, manufacturing, and retail—found it more challenging to secure financing. While the changes in lending terms were measured, banks began revising the conditions on new business loans, ensuring that they were not overly exposed to risk in case of an economic downturn.

Despite these more cautious lending practices, banks still sought to support ongoing business activity, especially in industries that were considered critical to the functioning of the economy. The adjustments, though noticeable, were relatively mild compared to what would come in the later months of 2020. As the pandemic's economic impact deepened, these early changes in commercial lending practices would evolve into more drastic measures in response to the heightened financial stress that businesses would face.

Digital Transformation in Lending

Automated Applications

Streamlined digital channels for faster loan processing with reduced face-to-face interaction

AI Credit Analysis

Integration of AI and machine learning for more accurate credit risk assessment

Rapid Deployment

Accelerated adoption of digital technologies ahead of originally planned timelines

Even before the pandemic took full force, banks were beginning to embrace the digital transformation in lending. Early in 2020, financial institutions accelerated the adoption of digital channels and automated systems for loan applications. This shift towards digital platforms allowed banks to process loan applications more quickly, reduce operational risks, and enhance the customer experience. In many ways, the pandemic acted as a catalyst, pushing financial institutions to adopt these technologies sooner than expected.

By integrating digital technologies, banks were able to streamline the loan application process, reduce face-to-face interactions, and make faster, data-driven decisions. The integration of AI and machine learning allowed lenders to more accurately predict borrower behavior and assess credit risk in real time. These technological advancements proved especially valuable as uncertainty mounted throughout the year, offering both consumers and banks more agility in an ever-changing environment.

Conclusion and Future Considerations

Key Takeaways

  • Early adjustments in lending practices positioned banks for greater resilience

  • Enhanced risk management strategies became a crucial foundation

  • Digital transformation accelerated ahead of planned timelines

  • Sector-specific lending adjustments reflected forward-thinking risk assessment

As February 2020 came to an end, the banking sector had already started making subtle, but important, changes in response to a growing sense of uncertainty. Early adjustments in lending practices, along with enhanced risk management strategies and a push toward digital transformation, laid the groundwork for how banks would handle the massive disruptions that were about to occur due to the COVID-19 pandemic. While these shifts were still in the early stages and were not yet fully realized across the sector, they marked a clear shift toward a more cautious, data-driven approach to lending and risk management.

Looking ahead, these early adjustments would prove invaluable as the COVID-19 crisis intensified, and the banking sector had to navigate an increasingly volatile economic landscape. The lessons learned from these initial changes in lending practices—such as the importance of flexibility, the role of digital transformation, and the need for robust risk management—remain crucial for managing future challenges. As we reflect on these early signals from February 2020, it's clear that the banking sector's preparedness for the uncertainty ahead would be a defining factor in how well it could weather the storm that was to come.

Financial Insights Team

Malcolm Henshaw

Specialist in financial risk management with 15+ years at leading global banks.

Ready to Get Started?

Check your rate in minutes with no impact on your credit score.